Pages

A Critical Analysis of Karl Keating and His Book The New Geocentrists

Purchase the Paperback
Purchase the PDF
Read the PDF
A Critical Analysis of Karl Keating and His Book "The New Geocentrists" (Paperback, w/free PDF)
This is Robert Sungenis, executive producer of the feature film, The Principle, and director of CAI Publishing, Inc. which publishes the Galileo Was Wrong series of books.

I went through Karl Keating’s new book, The New Geocentrists. Truth be told, I don’t think I’ve seen such a specious assortment of exaggerations innuendos, half truths and downright misinformation in all my years of reading, especially from someone who purports to be a Catholic. As I was going through the book, I sensed that Mr. Keating is a very desperate man, pulling out all the stops and engaging in a kind of slash and burn polemics with which I sensed even he was uncomfortable at times; hoping against hope that he can somehow stem the tide of the new Catholic apologetics he sees replacing his old and worn out apologetics that, in a word, did more capitulating to the world than it did defending against it.

I was so appalled at Keating’s treatment of some very honorable and dedicated Catholics, in addition to his spurious scientific arguments, that I resolved to answer as many of them as possible in order to show everyone exactly how he distorts the reality to his own advantage. Almost every page contains some kind of error, some of them quite deliberate, even when Mr. Keating knew the truth. I managed to pull out 111 of them in his 355 pages, but I could have done more. In addition to the science and the personal attacks, Keating makes my credibility his #1 target, dealing with topics that I have long since put on the shelf. Since he has decided to use them in an attempt to discredit me, I had no choice but to address them to protect my credibility.

Lastly, before you dive into this book, I want you to know that, after he published his book, Keating was challenged to a formal debate by two people of his own caliber, me and Christopher Ferrara. Keating declined to debate both of us. We can only conclude, then, that Keating is the kind of man who believes he can cast reputation-destroying aspersions against his opponents, but feels no responsibility to respond under cross examination from those very people who can best expose the weaknesses in his arguments. As such, I have little respect for the man and I have no problem calling him both a coward and dishonest; and this is the first time I have ever made such an accusation of anyone in all the thirty books I have written over the last two decades. No one but Karl Keating deserves that dishonor. Consequently, this book will have to suffice for a debate.

I couldn't have done better for Geocentrism than Karl Keating did on Catholic Answers Live!











Download Article Here

Mr. Keating couldn't be more wrong. At best, his argument shows that he has entirely missed the message of geocentrism. At worst, it shows that Keating has deliberately distorted the geocentrist’s message so that he can make it appear delusional. Similar to political questionnaires that frame questions in a specific manner to get the desired answer from the interviewee, Keating has done a similar thing with the “centrality” issue. He tactfully reversed the issues in order to make it appear as if geocentrists look at the world and themselves with a kind of narcissistic navel‐gazing. The truth is quite different, however. Geocentrists do not hold that if man wasn't in the center of the universe he would be unimportant. That would be like saying that if a father is not at home but is away on a business trip, his importance as a father is lessened. No, he is important to his family no matter what place he resides.

Welcome to Catholic Star Wars: The Principle v. Catholic Answers

  versus 

An Earth in the center of the universe just screams significance and purpose and, most of all, a Creator that truly cares for us. Why Jimmy Akin, and his boss, Karl Keating, would be against such an astounding possibility is a very great puzzle. Don’t they realize that if the scientific evidence puts Earth back in the center of the universe this means the Catholic Church is well on her way to being vindicated from all the jeers and accusations that have been thrown at it for the past four centuries since the time of Galileo? Don’t they see that with this new information the whole world could literally change overnight as mankind finally comprehends that the God who put the Earth in the center is the same God who revealed it to his Church and created the universe? What better platform is there from which to evangelize the world?

A Critique of Christopher Check's (President of Catholic Answers) Lecture on Galileo












Download PDF Here

In August 2014, Christopher Check of Catholic Answers gave a one‐hour lecture to a group of Catholics in Arlington, Virginia, titled, “Galileo on Trial: Why the Church was Right.” Whereas many previous years of Catholic consensus had understood the Church to be wrong on Galileo, Mr. Check represents a new tactic – declare the Church was right even though he believes it was wrong.

Anatomy of a Smear Campaign: Karl Keating and Mark Shea










Download PDF Here

I think it has become painfully obvious that Karl Keating, Mark Shea, and David Palm have become pathologically obsessed and deathly afraid of our movie, The Principle. In all my years as a Catholic, I’ve never seen such malicious vitriol. It usually comes from atheists and agnostics, but it’s sad to see it coming from people who wave the Christian banner. They actually think they are being good Christians by smearing other Christians who have an alternative interpretation of cosmological science (an interpretation that actually backs up the consensus of the Fathers and the two popes who condemned Galileo. Imagine that). Apparently we’ve hit a raw nerve.

Keating, Shea and Palm believe that any rejection of the popular interpretations of modern science (e.g., Big Bang, evolution, Copernicanism) simply makes the Catholic Church look bad in a modern society that has done a good job of removing itself from anything that has the marks of Catholic traditional teaching.

Since modernist Catholics now live in the age of ecumenism where everyone shakes hands and slaps each other on the back no matter how diverse their respective beliefs, it is simply passé to Keating, Shea and Palm that a Catholic should still be militant against something as popular as modern cosmology. After all, we all talk on cell phones and fly in jets, don’t we? What could be wrong with modern science? In fact, one could argue that the inventions of modern science make it much easier for the Catholic Church to communicate the Gospel to the world. What pope previous to our day could have envisioned that Catholic doctrine would be spread to the whole world over the Internet?

Catholic Answers: Still Bowing to Gideon's Idol
















Download PDF Here

I hadn’t seen a copy of Catholic Answers Magazine for quite a while, but I happen to see the March-April 2013 copy in the magazine rack of my church in Maryland. I’ll say this much. The magazine does its best with the caliber of people it has working for it. Basically, it attempts to correct misunderstandings about the Catholic faith that are commonly voiced from people of other religions. With that task it does a good job, and I recommend the magazine for that very purpose. The problem comes when Catholic Answers deals with more esoteric topics, such as science, heterodox clergy, American politics, and other sensitive issues.

Response to Robert Lockwood's This Rock Article on Galileo


















Download PDF Here

A few remarks on Robert Lockwood’s article on the Galileo affair ("The Anti‐Catholic’s Trump Card," July‐August 2009). It was admirable to see him try to defend the Church, but it wasn't convincing. The questions he never answers are: How could the Church of the 17th century, guided by the Holy Spirit, be so deceived in the very magisterial ranks it reveres as the protector of truth? How could the Church be led to believe that the Earth’s motion or non‐motion was a matter of faith and morals if it wasn't so? Did the Holy Spirit decide to forsake the popes and cardinals of the 17th century? Lockwood provides no answers. Although he admits the Church convicted Galileo in 1633 of being "vehemently suspect of heresy," he fails to reveal why. The reason was that the same tribunal had earlier declared heliocentrism "formally heretical." Galileo was only "suspected" rather than "guilty" because the tribunal couldn't determine whether he really believed it.

Fr. Raymond Brown's Hermeneutical Heresies


















Download PDF Here

In Catholic biblical hermeneutics, a turning point occurred during the reign of Pius XII. In his encyclical Divino Afflante Spiritu, Pius believed it to be beneficial that Catholic biblical scholars be able to use the interpretive tools of what is known as “historical criticism.” In a word, it could be said that historical criticism seeks to apply scientific analysis to a written document. Is the document authentic? What is its date? Who wrote it? Did the author borrow from other sources? What type of literature is it? How much is the author influenced by his culture? Did the author fabricate, exaggerate, or embellish his story? These and many other questions the historical critic brings to his document. The document studied can be any piece of literature of historical worth – a sonnet by Shakespeare, a Greek tragedy by Homer, or even the United States Constitution. In a word, the historical critic tries to get to the real essence of the document so that he can find out the real truth of what occurred, or at least, what he thinks is the real truth.



Catholic Answers and Ben Wiker: Another Misguided Attempt to Support the Theory of Evolution











Download PDF Here

Since so many Catholics have not bothered to study the complete picture of the scientific facts concerning the origins of life, they have accepted with almost god‐like devotion the claims of the loudest voices in modern science, namely, those who claim the earth is very old and that man evolved from apes. Among these devotees is Karl Keating, the president of Catholic Answers. On July 28, Catholic Answers Live presented a radio program titled: “Can Catholics Naturally Select Darwinism?” in which the special guest, Dr. Benjamin Wiker, presented another in a series of misguided attempts to support the theory of evolution and advance the idea that the Earth is billions of years old.